ÿþ

;5:A0=4@ " : 5=L =4NH:8





Copyright © Alexander Taratorin. All rights reserved.



N1>5 87<5=5=85 MB>3> B5:AB0, 0  B0:65 2>A?@>872545=85 53> 2 :><<5@G5A:8E  F5;OE

<>65B >ACI5AB2;OBLAO B>;L:> A A>3;0A8O 02B>@0. E-mail: amtar@pacbell.net.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



064K9    3>4,    AB>8B     B>;L:>    ?>O28BLAO   2  AC?5@<0@:5B0E 15AD>@<5==K<,

A;>=>?>4>1=K<  BCH0<     8=455:,     2     4CH5     <>59    ?>A5;O5BAO AC525@=0O

B@52>30.      ::C@0B      2     45=L  1;03>40@5=8O,   A>   <=>9   2A5340    GB>

=81C4L =5E>@>H55  ?@>8AE>48B.   ">  B@C10  C    A>A5459 ;>?=5B  8   <>N  :><=0BC

70;L5B,  B>  2   <0H8=5 AB5:;> @07>1LNB.   ?0@C ;5B =0704  <5=O 4065 >AB0=>28;8

=0    02B>AB@045    8    >B257;8    2  CG0AB>:-     A?CB0;8       A      :5<-B>,

?>-?LO=8 C48@02H8<  >B ?>;8F88.  @>AB> :0:>9-B>  7;>9 @>:.



> G53> C6 BCB ?>45;05HL, 45=L 1;03>40@5=8O ?@>AB> =04> ?5@568BL, :0:  AB8E89=>5

154AB285. >MB><C, :>340 @0740;AO B5;5D>==K9  72>=>:, O @5H8;, GB> >B  AC4L1K =5

C945HL, 8 @5H8B5;L=> ?>4=O; B@C1:C. 2>=8; =4@59, <>9 AB0@K9 ?@8OB5;L.



  @825B, :>;8AL =5<54;5==>, BK :C40-=81C4L =0 ?@074=8:8 C57605HL?   2K?0;8;  >=

A:>@>3>2>@:>9.



  0 =5B, 2>>1I5-B>. 



  =0G8B, @5H5=>,  ?@8E>48HL :> <=5!   =8:0:8E >B3>2>@>:,  O B51O 7=0N,  A59G0A

=0G=5HL  >B=5:820BLAO, AAK;0BLAO  =0 @01>BC.  065 A;KH0BL  =8G53> =5  65;0N!  

=4@59 2K:@8:=C; 2A5 MB> =0 >4=>< 4KE0=88.



   =4@59,  BK  B>;L:>  =5  >18609AO.     /  ?@54AB028;  A515  B>;ABCN, ?>:@KBCN

?C?K@KH:0<8, 8AA8=O-A87CN  8=4NH0GLN ;O6:C,  8 A>4@>3=C;AO.    #  <5=O :CG0 45;.

5B, O =5 >B:07K20NAL, O ?@>AB> ?>:0 =5 <>3C >15I0BL.



  /  B0: 8  7=0;...    >;>A 53>  AB0; E@8?;>-?@>=8:=>25==K<.    C  =5 1C4L  BK

A2>;>GLN, A>AB02L <=5 :><?0=8N.



  'B>-=81C4L A;CG8;>AL?   >G5<C-B> 2 <>5< 2>>1@065=88 A;>68;0AL 2 BC 65 A5:C=4C

6CB:0O  :0@B8=0:  =4@59 >AB0;AO  A>2A5<  >48=, 8  5A;8  O =5  ?@84C,  =025@=O:0

=0?L5BAO 8 ?>:>=G8B A A>1>9, 8;8 A45;05B 5I5 :0:85-=81C4L 3;C?>AB8. 



  >=8<05HL...   =4@59 A:>=DC65==> :0H;O=C; 2 B@C1:C.   "0:0O 8AB>@8O, =018;8AL

2 3>AB8 40;L=85 @>4AB25==8:8, 0  C <5=O >B =8E 2>7=8:05B  E@>=8G5A:>5 =5A20@5=85

65;C4:0.  0?820NAL  2  4>A:C, =8G53>  A  A>1>9  ?>45;0BL =5  <>3C.    >4=><C  

=5C4>1=>.  >@>G5,  5A;8  @O4><  =5  1C45B  =>@<0;L=>3>  G5;>25:0,  O  A28E=CAL.

@8545HL?



  0 > G5< @073>2>@,   >?5H8; O.   / 8 =5 7=0;, GB> C B51O B0:85 @>4AB25=...  ">

5ABL, ?@>1;5<K.   =5 AB0;> =5;>2:>.   / 1CBK;:C ?@8=5AC, 8;8, ;CGH5 B>@B8:?



  8:0:8E B>@B8:>2! "0I8  425 1CBK;:8,   @5H8B5;L=>  @O2:=C; =4@59, 8 O  ?>=O;,

GB> ?@8OB5;L <>9 459AB28B5;L=> ?>?0;  2 AC@>2K9 ?5@5?;5B AC4L1K. =  2A5340 A;K;

6CB:8< A;0AB5=>9: 2 <>;>4>AB8 ?@>A;028;AO  B5<, GB> =0 ABC45=G5A:>9 25G5@8=:5  2

>48=>G:C A;>?0; B>@B, ?@54=07=0G02H89AO 4;O >@02K 3>AB59. 



;O A<O3G5=8O A8BC0F88, :C?;5=K 1K;8 2 <0;5=L:>< @CAA:>< <03078=G8:5 425 2  <5@C

C2O4H8E A5;54:8, 1CE0=:0 G5@=>3> E;510, 8 ?> 25AL<0 702KH5==>9 F5=5 ?0@0 1CBK;>:

"C10=A:>9". ! B0:8< 0@A5=0;>< O GC2AB2>20; A51O 2> 2A5>@C688. 



=4@59 68;  =0 4@C3><  :>=F5 3>@>4:0,  C A0<>3>  ?>4=>68O 3>@.  > ?CB8 A;CG8;AO

4>A04=K9  8=F845=B:  =0  ?5@5:@5AB:5  O  5420  C25@=C;AO  >B  :0:>3>-B>  848>B0,

=0@O65==>3> 8=4N:><. =4N: A :2>EB0=85< ?@K30; <564C ?@>5760NI8<8 02B><>18;O<8 8

@07<0E820; ?;0:0B><,  8725I0NI8< 2>48B5;59  > 3@0=48>7=>9  @0A?@>4065 8=4NH5:  2

A>A54=5< AC?5@<0@:5B5.  @8H;>AL @57:>  70B>@<>78BL, AC<:0  A ?@>4C:B0<8  C?0;0,

:C?;5==K5 1CBK;:8  C:0B8;8AL ?>4  A845=L5.   ?>7048 <5=O  3;CE> C40@8;>,  ?>B><

70725=5;> 8 ?>AK?0;>AL AB5:;>   2>48B5;O< 84CI8E A;54>< <0H8= O2=> =5 ?>257;>.



=4N: @0AB5@O==> ?>A<>B@5;  =0 45;> @C:  A2>8E, 8, ?>=O2,  GB> 53> A59G0A  1C4CB

18BL, B@CA;82> @5B8@>20;AO.  AG0ABLN, ?>AB@0402H85 1K;8 F5;K 8 =52@548<K,  5A;8

=5 AG8B0BL  ?><OB>3> 10<?5@0  8 @0718B>9  D0@K. '5@57  =5A:>;L:> <8=CB ?>O28;0AL

?>;8F8O,  20H ?>:>@=K9  A;C30 =0O154=8G0;  =0 @8BC0;L=CN  ?B8FC, 8,  A GC2AB2><

2K?>;=5==>3> 3@0640=A:>3> 4>;30, ?>5E0; 40;LH5. 



C GB> 65, ?> 2A5< ?@87=0:0<, 45=L 1;03>40@5=8O =0G0;AO. 5B, =5 ?> 4CH5 <=5 MB>

?@074=5AB2>.  7OBL,  : ?@8<5@C,  4CE>2=>-8AB>@8G5A:CN  ?>4>?;5:C. =0  =03;O4=>

4>:07K205B, GB>  E>@>H85 45;0  2>7=03@0640NBAO 40;5:>  =5 2A5340,  =5 25745, 8 2

=54>AB0B>G=><  :>;8G5AB25.  ><8@0;8  :>340-B>  ?5@2K5  ?8;83@8<K  >B  3>;>40, 0

<5AB=K5  8=459FK  ?@8=5A;8  8<  2  ?>40@>:  C185==KE  8=4NH5:.  '0ABL ?8;83@8<>2

(7;>@04=> ?>4>7@520N,  GB> 40;5:>  =5 ;CGH0O  8E G0ABL)  2 @57C;LB0B5  2K68;0, 8

@04>AB=> B5E A0<KE 8=459F52 8AB@518;0. 



> >3 A =59, A 8AB>@859, >=0 402=> 701KB0. / ?>GB8-GB> C25@5=, GB> 45=L 8=4NH:8

O2;O5BAO  5AB5AB25==K< ?@>O2;5=85<  8=AB8=:B0 A0<>A>E@0=5=8O.  5 E20B05B  ;N4O<

68@>2,  8  2>B,  =0:0=C=5  78<K,  ?>4A>7=0B5;L=>,  70G0ABCN  ?@>B82  A2>59 2>;8,

?@>8AE>48B 2>A?>;=5=85 @5AC@A>2, 2>72545==>5 2 @0=3 =0F8>=0;L=>3> ?@074=5AB20. 



=> 8  ?>=OB=>, 0<5@8:0=FK  - =0@>4  EC4>I02K9 8  0A:5B8G5A:89. =8  =5 ?LNB, =5

:C@OB  (GB>,  2  >1I5<-B>  ?>=OB=>:  :C@8BL  >1KG=>  E>G5BAO,  :>340   2K?L5HL),

C?>B@51;ONB 2 ?8IC 2A5 B>;L:> 8A:;NG8B5;L=> ?>;57=>5 8 >15768@5==>5, 0 ?>B><C   

1572:CA=>5, 8,  :0: ?@028;>,  2K7K20NI55 65;G=>ABL  E0@0:B5@0, ?5@5@0AB0NICN  A>

2@5<5=5<  2 @0:  65;C4:0.   B>;L:> >48=-548=AB25==K9  @07 2  3>4C C  01>@835=>2

>B:07K20NB B>@<>70, 8 >=8  15AABK4=>-@8BC0;L=K< >1@07>< >168@0NBAO ?>GB8-GB>  4>

?>B5@8 A>7=0=8O. 



AOG5A:85  <0;>@0728BK5  ?;5<5=0 2  B0:>9  A8BC0F88 701820;8  8  60@8;8 =081>;55

C?8B0==KE ?;5==KE, 8;8 4065 A>?;5<5==8:>2 (2 ?;>E85 3>40 ?;5==KE =5 A;CG0;>AL  8

?@8E>48;>AL  65@B2>20BL 548=8F0<8  @048 A?0A5=8O  :>;;5:B820).   =0H5 3C<0==>5

2@5<O, >4=0:>, 2 ;N4>54AB25 =5B =8:0:>9 =5>1E>48<>AB8, : B><C 65 >=>  70?@5I5=>,

4065 2  @0<:0E =0F8>=0;L=KE  B>@65AB2, 8  2 F5;OE  ?@>?8B0=8O 0<5@8:0=FK ?>74=59

>A5=LN 6CNB 8=4N:>2 8 8=4NH5:.



;O  CA?>:>5=8O 3@0640=A:>9  A>25AB8, <>738  >1K20B5;59, 70?C30==KE  :>;8G5AB2><

:0;>@89  8  5654=52=K<8  =>@<0<8  E>;5AB5@>;0,  >18;L=>  ?@><K20NBAO  A@54AB20<8

845>;>38G5A:>9  ?@>?030=4K,  2=CH0NI8<8  <KA;L  >  B><,  GB>  AJ545=85  8=4N:0  

?0B@8>B8G5A:89  4>;3. >  A?CB=8:>2K< 8  :015;L=K< :0=0;0<  B5;52845=8O >48=  70

4@C38<  :@CBOB  A;57;82K5  D8;L<K  A  >4=>>1@07=>-?>2B>@ONI8<AO  AN65B><:   B5F

(A:@><=K9 B>@3>2K9 035=B, :>B>@>3>  2>B-2>B C2>;OB 157 2KE>4=>3>  ?>A>18O), <0BL

(A5:@5B0@H0 =5E>@>H53>  1>AA0, @07@K20NI0OAO  <564C @01>B>9  8 45BL<8),  AK= 8;8

1@0B, 4>GL, =0  EC4>9 :>=5F, A5AB@0  (:0: ?@028;>, ?>?02H85  2 ?;>ECN :><?0=8N),

2A5  >=8 :0:  =07;> =8:0:  =5 <>3CB  4>1@0BLAO 4><>9  8 >B:CH0BL  2 :@C3C  A5<L8

8=4NH:C A :;N:25==K< A>CA><. >=:C@5=BK, ?@5ABC?=8:8, <564C=0@>4=K5  B5@@>@8ABK,

4065 :><<C=8AB8G5A:85 H?8>=K 45;0NB 2A5 >B =8E 7028AOI55, GB>1K @07@CH8BL  AKB>5

A5<59=>5 B>@65AB2>,  8 B5<  A0<K< ?>4>@20BL  ?>?>;=5=85 >@30=87<0  68@>-C3;52>4>

15;:0<8.  > 70:0=G8205BAO  2A5 E>@>H>,  : D8=0;C  >B @8BC0;L=>9  ?B8FK, :0:  8

?>;>65=>, >AB0NBAO @>6:8 40 =>6:8. 



                                       *



=4@59 AB>O; =0 ;C609:5 >:>;> A2>59 425@8, 8 2A<0B@820;AO 2 ?@>57602H85 ?> C;8F5

<0H8=K. #28452 <5=O, >= @04>AB=> =0G0; @07<0E820BL @C:0<8.



  C =0:>=5F-B>! '53> B0: ?>74=>?



  'CBL @5:;0<=>3> 8=4N:0 =5 704028;, ?@8H;>AL ?>;8F8N 4>6840BLAO.



  >4:C ?@8257?   =4@59 AB@040;LG5A:8 ?><>@I8;AO.   0209, A:>@55, 70  2AB@5GC,

  >= 4@>60I59 @C:>9 A25@=C; ?@>1:C 8 @5H8B5;L=> A45;0; 3;>B>: ?@O<> 87 3>@;KH:0,

:0:-B>  42CA<KA;5==> ?>4<83=C2  <=5.   @57C;LB0B5, O  =0G0; ?>4>7@520BL  A2>53>

4@C30 2 B09=>< 0;:>3>;87<5.   A5, B5?5@L 2K682C.



  "K > G5<?



  !59G0A A0< C2848HL, 2 =0BC@0;L=CN 25;8G8=C. / B515 ?>-E>@>H5<C A>25BCN: 2K?59,

?>:0 =5 ?>74=>, GB>1K =5@2=K5 >:>=G0=8O =5 ?5@53>@5;8. 



  0 1C45B B515, B>65 <=5, =52@0AB5=8: =0H5;AO. "K G53>, 87-70 @>4AB25==8:>2 B0:

?5@568205HL? %0!  / B515  ?>;CGH5 8AB>@8N  @0AA:06C: /  ?OBL ;5B  68; A  B5I59 2

>4=>:><=0B=>9 :20@B8@5, 8....



 0AA:07 A2>9 O 70:>=G8BL  =5 CA?5;, 25@=55 =5  A<>3, B0: :0: :  :0;8B:5 ?>4:0B8;

O@:>-:@0A=>3>   F25B0   <8:@>02B>1CA,   A   =5?@024>?>4>1=>-G5@=K<8    :>;5A0<8.

2B><>18;L, :070;>AL, B>;L:> GB>  A>H5; A @5:;0<=>3> ?@>A?5:B0.  5B@>2>5 AB5:;>

53>  ?5@5;820;>AL  ?5@;0<CB@><,  0  DN75;O6  1;5AB5;,  25@=55  A25@:0;,   :064K<

<8;;8<5B@>< A2>59  ?>25@E=>AB8, B0:  GB> 3;070  =0G0;8 G5A0BLAO,  :0: 1K205B  2>

2@5<O 1C9=>3> F25B5=8O 2AOG5A:8E 2@54=KE B@02 8 :CAB0@=8:>2. > A25@:0=85,  E>BO

8  ?>@078;>  <5=O,  =5  <>3;>  >B2;5GL  273;O4  >B  =5?@024>?>4>1=>3> :>;8G5AB20

2AOG5A:8E  0=B5==  8  ?@8A?>A>1;5=89, @07<5AB82H8EAO  =0  :@KH5  8 425@OE  MB>3>

A@54AB20 ?5@542865=8O.



N: 2 :@KH5 <8:@>02B>1CA0 1K; >B:@KB, 8 >BBC40, :0: 87 10H5=:8 B0=:0,  284=5;0AL

GLO-B> 3>;>20 2 =0CH=8:0E, B0< 65 @0A?>;030;8AL B@5=>6=8: 8 =0?@02;5==0O 2  =0HC

AB>@>=C   2845>:0<5@0.  @8   MB><,  87   >:=0  02B><>18;O   =0  =0A   =0F5;8;AO

D>B>3@0D8G5A:89 >1J5:B82, :064K5 425-B@8 A5:C=4K 7;>2@54=> ?>;KE0NI89 2A?KH:>9.



  'B> MB>?   A B@C4>< 2K4028; 87 A51O O, 706<C@820OAL >B D>B>2A?KH:8.



  @>HC  ;N18BL 8  60;>20BL,    ?@>F548; =4@59  A:2>7L 7C1K.  15I0==>5 O2;5=85

?@8@>4K 2 @0730@5.



  4@02AB2C9B5, E>7O520 4>@>385!    25@L <8:@>02B>1CA0 >BJ5E0;0 2 AB>@>=C.    

2>B <K 20A 8  70A=O;8. ! B@5E @0:C@A>2,  <564C ?@>G8<, 2 48=0<8:5.  / =5402=> =0

@0A?@>4065 :C?8; D>B>0??0@0B, C =53>  B0:>9 @568<: ?@>3@0<<8@C5HL, 8 >=  A=8<05B

4204F0BL :04@>2  2 <8=CBC.  >B>< <>6=>  <>=B8@>20BL :0:  <C;LBD8;L<. >4 BKAOGC

AB>8;, 0 O 27O; 70 B@8AB0. 0;O! 0;O! C 345 65 BK ?@>?0;0? 0;>G:0!



!CH5AB2>,  87  :>B>@>3> 8725@30;8AL  ?>B>:8  B5E=8:>-M:>=><8G5A:8E 40==KE,  1K;>

=52KA>:8< 8  >1;040;> :C@G02>-G5@=>9  2>;>A0B>ABLN 2A5E  2K40NI8EAO :>=5G=>AB59,

:@><5 3>;>2K. 45B>  O2;5=85 1K;> 2  A>25@H5==> =5 ?>4E>4OI85  : A57>=C E>;>4=KE

25B@>2  H>@BK  ?;0=B0B>@A:>3>  B8?0,  O@:8E  B@>?8G5A:8E  @0AF25B>:  @C10H:C   A

:>@>B:8<8  @C:020<8 8  78<=85, 2KA>:85  H=C@>20==K5 70<H52K5  1>B8:8, 4>AB0NI85

?>GB8-GB> 4> :>;5=.



  5B@  @:04L528G, 42>N@>4=K9  4O4O,    AB@040;LG5A:8 2K4>E=C;  =4@59.    MB>

4@C3 <>9, ;5:A0=4@.



  5BO,   687=5CB25@640NI5 ?>4B25@48;>  B@>?8G5A:>5 ACI5AB2>, B@OAO <>N @C:C.   

G5=L  ?@8OB=>.    AC?@C3C <>N  0;59  7>2CB.  0;O! 0;CA8:!  C  :C40  65 >=0

?>4520;0AL. >B  25G=> MB8  65=I8=K 70AB@O=CB  ?> A2>8<  8=B8<=K< 45;0<,  4065 2

02B><>18;5 8<8 C<C4@ONBAO 70=OBLAO. ;07 40  3;07 70 =8<8 =C65=. %0-E0-E0!    =

A=O; A ?>OA0 ?>@B0B82=CN @0F8N.



   =5  B>65...  G5=L...     O @0AB5@O;AO  >B  HCB>G5:  5B@0  @:04L528G0  8 A

C482;5=85< ?>A<>B@5; =0 @0F8N.



  >;:8  ">;:8,    >1JOA=8; 42>N@>4=K9  4O4O. G5=L  C4>1=0O 25I8F0, @5:><5=4CN.

>B, =0?@8<5@, ?>H;8 <K ?@>4C:BK ?>:C?0BL: 0;O 2 >2>I=>9 >B45;, O,  =0BC@0;L=>,

2 <OA=>9, 2A?><8=05HL GB>-B> ?> ?CB8, ?5@53>20@8205HLAO.  C6 ?@> B>@3>2K9 F5=B@

8 3>2>@8BL =5 ?@8E>48BAO.  0AAB>O=8O - 2 :8;><5B@K. 



  5BO, MB> BK? @85<!    0740;>AL 87 @0F88.



  0;O! C 345 65 BK ?@>?0405HL, G5AB=>5 A;>2>, =5A8 :0<5@C, 8 =8 2 :>5<  A;CG05

=5 ?@5:@0I09 A=8<0BL.  -B> 65 8AB>@8O,  A5<59=K9 0@E82. AB@5G0  =0 -;L15, <>6=>

4065 B0: 2K@078BLAO. >B>< A>AB0@8<AO 8 A<>B@5BL 1C45<, 2>B 254L :0:....



  5BO,  0 5A;8  10B0@59:0 AO45B?  @85<!    A <5B0;;8G5A:8<  E@8?>< 2>7@078; 87

@0F88 3>;>A. 



  / 70?0A=CN 27O;,   CA?>:>8;> AC?@C3C 2>;>A0B>-B@>?8G5A:>5 A>740=85.    AB0B8,

8 :0<5@C, 8 10B0@59:8 :C?8; 7045H52>. %>B8B5 =0CG8BLAO, ;5:A0=4@?  BK, =4@59,

B>65 ?>CG8AL, ?>:0 O 682. "0: 2>B: =0 @>645AB2> >1JO28;8 A:84:C 2 4204F0BL  ?OBL

?@>F5=B>2,  0  O  70E20B8;  ?@>H;>3>4=NN 3075BC,  2K@570;  >1JO2;5=85,  C  =8E 2

?@54K4CI55 @>645AB2> 1K;0  @0A?@>4060 ?> ?>;-F5=K.  / 2A5 3075BK  E@0=N =0 B0:>9

A;CG09. C, ?@54AB02;O5B5, ?>:070; 8<, 3>2>@N: :>=:C@5=BK A:8=C;8 ?>;>28=C, 0  O

2>7L<C 70 B@5BL. =8 C?5@;8AL, => :C40 B0<, O =5 >BABC?0;. 



  5BO  C <5=O  B0:>9 M=BC780AB!  = :064CN  =545;N 87CG05B  2A5 3075BK, GB> 345

?@>405BAO,  2A5  =>28=:8...  K?8AK205B, A@02=8205B.  9,  74@02AB2C9B5,  A MB>9

:0<5@>9 2A5 =0 A25B5 ?>701C45HL!   @>87=5A;> 2A5 MB> HC@H0I55 ?;0BL5 A B>@G0I59

2<5AB> 3>;>2K 2845>:0<5@>9.



  0:>==0O ?>;>28=0, ?@>HC ;N18BL 8 60;>20BL. ;5:A0=4@, MB> : 20< >B=>A8BAO,  0

B>  C 20A  D878>=><8O :0:0O-B>  :8A;0O, A;>2=>  2K G5<-B>  =54>2>;L=K. ;8  20<

0;>G:0 =5 =@028BAO? %0-%0-%0! 



  0 O, A>1AB25==>.   2>N@>4=K9 4O4NH:0 =0G0; <5=O @074@060BL.   A5 =>@<0;L=>.



  (CGC! (CGC!  MB> =0H A 0;59 ?>40@>: =0 45=L 1;03>40@5=8O,   5B@  @:04L528G

A   B>@65AB2CNI8<   2K@065=85<  ;8F0   ?@>BO=C;   =4@5N  =5GB>   E@><8@>20==>5,

=0?><8=0NI55 ?;>4 =5AG0AB=>9 ;N128 <548F8=A:>3> H?@8F0 A <0=><5B@><.



  'B> MB>?



  C :0: 65, B5<=K5 2K ;N48! -B> - B5@<><5B@ 4;O >?@545;5=8O AB5?5=8  3>B>2=>AB8

8=4NH:8.  >AB05HL  87 4CE>2:8,  2BK:05HL  2=CB@L. A;8  2  3;C18=5 B5;0  B@8AB0

A5<L45AOB ?OBL 3@04CA>2 8A?>;=8;8AL - <>6=> :CH0BL. /, :AB0B8, 8 8A?>;=8B5;L=8FC

3;02=>9 @>;8 ?@8257. >4:>@<8BL,  B0: A:070BL, ?;5<O==8G:0. 0;O,  A=8<09 A:>@55

2K=>A ?B8FK!



   0G5<?     >?@>A  MB>B  70AB@O;  C  =4@5O  2  3>@;5,  B0:  :0:  A87>5 B5;>,

2KB0A:8205<>5 87  10306=8:0 @>4AB25==8:0<8,  @07<5@>< 8  F25B>< A2>8< =0?><8=0;>

7@5;>3>,  C<5@H53>  4=O  B@8-G5BK@5  =0704  3@0640=8=0,  AB@0402H53>  ?@8  687=8

>68@5=85< A@54=59 AB5?5=8.



  N1;N O MB>B ?@074=8:,   5B@ @:04L528G, A>?O, 2>;>: B@C? ?> 4>@>6:5, 254CI59

2  4><.    CH52=K9  >=,  @>4=KE ?>28405HL,  ?>A848HL  ?>-G5;>25G5A:8, ?>:CH05HL

4>AKB0. AB0B8,    :0:0O-B>  <KA;L G@572KG09=>9  206=>AB8 ?>A5B8;0  3>ABO, 8  >=

>B?CAB8; 4>E;CN 8=459:C, :0:  =8 2 G5< =5  1K20;> 2KB5@52 >:@>202;5==K5 @C:8  >1

@C10H:C.   0: 65 B0:,  O 3>ABO 20H53> 4> A8E  ?>@ 2 :0@B>B5:C =5 70=5A!     87

:0@<0=0  H>@B  872;5:;>AL  ?;>A:>-G5@=>5 A  :@>E>B=K<8  :;028H0<8  8 M;5:B@>==K<

8=48:0B>@><.



  5 =04> 2  :0@B>B5:C,   ?@8 2845  @0A?@>AB5@B>3> =0 4>@>6:5 8=4NH0GL53>  B@C?0

<5=O =0G0;> <CB8BL.   5 E>GC.



  728=5=8O  =5 ?@8=8<0NBAO!  %0-E0! 4@5A>:,  B5;5D>=G8:.   2>B MBC  :>@>1>G:C

<>6=> :015;5< ?>4:;NG8BL : ?5@A>=0;L=><C :><?LNB5@C. 5IL! 



   <>65B  1KBL, 2K?8BL G53>-=81C4L  E>B8B5?   2>2@5<O  2<5H0;AO =4@59.    5B@

@:04L528G, 2>4>G:8? 0;>G:0, :0: =0AG5B 28=F0? @0A=5=L:>3>? >60;C9AB0! C, 70

2AB@5GC!



  5 >B:06CAL, =5 =0459B5AL!   5B@ @:04L528G AC=C; M;5:B@>==CN 70?8A=CN :=86:C

2 :0@<0= 8  A C4>2>;LAB285< ?@8G<>:=C;,  C28452 B0@5;>G:C A  =0@570==K< 4>;L:0<8

A>;5=K< >3C@F><.   04> 20< ?>@B0B82=K9 ?K;5A>A ?>:070BL, >= C <5=O 2 <0H8=5. 



#?><8=0=85 ?K;5A>A0  1K;> =0AB>;L:>  =5>6840==K<, GB>  O 274@>3=C;  8 @0A?;5A:0;

2>4:C. 



  G5=L C4>1=0O 25I8F0. !0< 65 =0<CA>@8;, A0< A>1AB25==>5 45@L<> 8 C18@05HL.  %0

E0-E0!



/ 706<C@8;AO 8  2K?8; @N<:C, ?@542:CH0O  >AB0B>: 25G5@0 8  B@>30B5;L=CN A5<59=CN

B@0?57C.



  C GB> 65, A59G0A 8=4N:0 70@O48<...  4CE>2>G:C 53>... "LDC BK... 



  'B>?   =4@59 70:CA8; 3C1C.



  0,  =5 2;5705B,    5B@  @:04L528G C65  =0?>;>28=C 70AC=C;  <5@B2CN ?B8FC  2

4CE>2:C, => BCH0 70AB@O;0, ;O6:8  B>@G0;8 A=0@C68, 8 <5H0;8 425@:5  70:@KBLAO.  

04> 65, 4> G53> C 20A 2A5  <8=80BN@=>5, 2 <>59 :CE=5 A;>=0 <>6=> 70?5GL.  %0-E0

E0!



   !;CH09B5, 5B@  @:04L528G, 1@>A8;8  1K 2K  55. 0:CA:8  ?>;=>, ?@>?045B.   

A>4@>3=C;AO O.



  -B> BK ?@5:@0B8, 5:A0=4@. 0:>9 65 45=L 1;03>40@5=8O 157 8=4NH:8! >B  B>;L:>

@570BL ?@845BAO. 0;O! 0;5G:0! @8=5A8 87 10306=8G:0 <>9 ;N18<K9 =>6.



  0 70G5<, 2>B 65 =>68:...   2<5H0;AO =4@59.



   C <5=O >A>15==K9, A M;5:B@>?@82>4><. 570BC?;ONI89AO.



  E,   70AB>=0; =4@59.   / =5 4>682C 4> ?>=545;L=8:0,   H5?=C; >= <=5 =0  CE>.

  -B8 N=K5 B5E=8:8 A =>G52:>9 ?@85E0;8. 0209 =0?L5<AO 4> A:>BA:>3> A>AB>O=8O, 8

?>1KAB@59. 



  I5 2>B 745AL =04@578: 7025@H8<. 0;L, :>=5G=>, B0:>3> 725@O :@><A0BL,   =>6 A

2873>< 2@570;AO  2 A8=NH=K9  B@C?, 8  1@K738 <CB=>9,  A<5H0==>9 A  ?B8GL8< 68@><

:@>28, ?>:@K;8 :0D5;L=CN ?;8B:C =0 :CE>==>< ?>;C.   > =8G53> C6 =5 ?>45;05HL.



  >A?>48,   <KA;5==>  27<>;8;AO O, ?@5>4>;520O 4C@=>BC.    5A<>B@O =0 B>,  GB>

B51O  =5B, ?@>HC,  O28 7=0<5=85,  8A?5?5;8 MBC  304:CN ?B8FC  =515A=K< >3=5<.  

87102L  =0A  >B MB>3>  =54>@07C<5=8O  2 H>@B0E,  =C  GB> B515  AB>8B!  5B,    O

8A?C30;AO 8 @5H8;, GB> AB0=>2;NAL =52@0AB5=8:><,   5B@0 @:04L528G0  8A?5?5;OBL

=5 =04>, ?CABL >= ?@>AB> 8AG57=5B, ?> 2>7<>6=>AB8 15A:@>2=K< >1@07><.



  >B B0:!    5B@ @:04L528G, =0?@O3H8AL, 70:@K;-B0:8 425@L 4CE>2:8.    "5?5@L

2:;NG05<&      C:0 53>  ?@>BO=C;0AL :  2K:;NG0B5;N, I5;:C;0  8<, 8  2 MBC  <8=CBC

A;CG8;>AL  =5GB>  A25@EJ5AB5AB25==>5:    4CE>2:5  =5E>@>H>  B@5A=C;>, 2A?KE=C;>

D8>;5B>2K< >3=5<, 70B5< 87 =55 ?>20;8;  G5@=K9 4K<, 8 >4=>2@5<5==> 2> 2A5<  4><5

?>30A A25B, 2 @57C;LB0B5 G53> AB0;> A>25@H5==> B5<=>. 



  "2>N <0BL,   =5 A45@60;AO 5B@ @:04L528G.   ">:>< 45@=C;0, A2>;>GL.



  04> 65, :0: 1KAB@> >A5=LN B5<=55B,   C4828;AO =4@59.   I5 G0A =0704  A>;=F5

A25B8;>.



  5BO, GB>  A;CG8;>AL?   0;N  <>6=> 1K;> 157>H81>G=>  >?@545;8BL 2 B5<=>B5  ?>

3>@OI5<C  3;07:C  2845>:0<5@K,  70?5G0B;52H59  70A>2K20=85  ?B8FK  2  4CE>2:C  8

?>A;54>202H89 M;5:B@>H>: AC?@C30.



  =459:0, ?>E>65, :>=B0:B 70:>@>B8;0. @>1:8 2K18;>.



  $>=0@8  =0 C;8F5  B>65 ?>30A;8,    7;>@04=>  :>=AB0B8@>20; =4@59.    >B  GB>

1K205B, :>340 2 :064>9 0<5@8:0=A:>9 A5<L5 =0 ?>;=CN <>I=>ABL 2@C10NB 4CE>2:8. 



  8G53>, 1C45< C68=0BL ?@8 A25G0E, A5;54:>9 A G5@=K< E;51><,   2>>4CH528;AO  O.

  =459:8 =5 1C45B, 40 74@02AB2CNB 8=459FK! 



  5BO,   0;O A25B8;0AL ?@>?;K20NI8<  >3>=L:>< 2845>:0<5@K.    O 20A  2A5E B0:

E>@>H> 2 >1J5:B825 286C!



  8 >4=0 <8=CB:0 AJ5<:8 =5  ?@>?045B, =5 2>;=C9B5AL. # :0<5@K 5ABL  A?5F80;L=K9

=>G=>9 @568<.   A 3>@4>ABLN :>=AB0B8@>20; 3>;>A 5B@0 @:04L528G0.



K =0>IC?L 2KH;8 87 4><0. ><  70 4><>< ?>3@C60;8AL 2> BL<C. I5  345-B> 240;5:5

GB>-B> 2A?KE820;>,  => 8  >=> ?>30A;>,  8 AB0;>  B5<=> 8  B8E>.   24@C3, :0: ?>

:><0=45, 2 3>@>45 702K;8 A>10:8.  @87=0BLAO, ?> A?8=5 C <5=O  ?>1560;8 <C@0H:8.

, ?>E>65, =5 B>;L:> C <5=O.



  0 GB> 65 MB> B0:>5 ?@>8AE>48B! / A59G0A 2 ?>;8F8N ?>72>=N,   5B@  @:04L528G

=5@5H8B5;L=> ?8A:=C; <>18;L=K< B5;5D>=><.   'B> 70 5@C=40, A83=0;0 =5B.



  !?CB=8: 2K@C18;AO,   A 284>< 7=0B>:0  70O28; O.   5B5>@8BK, =8G53> A =8<8  =5

?>45;05HL.



  # <5=O >;:8-">;:8 2 ?>;8F59A:><  480?07>=5 A83=0; ?@8=8<05B...    @0F88  GB>

B> E@8?5;> 8 27@K20;>AL I5;G:0<8.    745AL 2A5 <>;G8B.   1;040B5;L M;5:B@>==>9

B5E=8:8,  =0G0;  B5@OBL  C25@5==>ABL 2  CAB>9G82>ABL  F828;870F88,  8 3>;>A  53>

4@>3=C;. 



  "8H5,   0;O =0:>=5F 2K:;NG8;0 2845>:0<5@C   'B> MB>? !;KH8B5?



0 C;8F5 70@KG0;>, @0740;AO B@5A: 8 2=CH8B5;L=>3> @07<5@0 G5@=0O B5=L A  B@5A:><

B:=C;0AL 2 701>@, >B3>@06820NI89 =0A >B A>A5459.



  54254L!   0;O 8A?C30==> 2A:@8:=C;0 8 1>;L=> 2?8;0AL =>3BO<8 2 <>N @C:C.



  @87;8.    ;03>4CH=>  ?>4B25@48; O,  ?KB0OAL 2KA2>1>48BL  @C:C.    / 2 3075B5

G8B0;, 2 ?@>H;>< 3>4C <542548F0 A <542560B0<8 A 3>@ A?CAB8;0AL, 0::C@0B =0  45=L

1;03>40@5=8O. -B> >=8 2 3>@>4 =0  70?0E ?>4BO3820NBAO: 2AN4C 8=4N:>2 60@OB, 0  C

725@N3 682>BK ?>42>48B. 



  0<0!   5B@ @:04L528G, ?>E>65, CB@0B8; 2AOG5A:85 687=5==K5 >@85=B8@K . 



   >B  B0:8<  >=  8  1C45B,  >1I89  :@878A  :0?8B0;87<0,     =5>6840==>   =0G0;

45:;0<8@>20BL =4@59.  !C4O ?>  3>;>AC, >=  C65 87@O4=>  70E<5;5;.    2>740ABAO

:064><C ?> 45;0< 53>.



  0;O,  =5 A;CH09  53>. 0  <=>9!    5B@ @:04L528G  2 420  ?@K6:0 4>1@0;AO 4>

A2>53> <8:@>02B>1CA0, 2?8E=C;  2 =53> AC?@C3C,  8, 27@5252 42830B5;5<,  A 2873><

27O; A <5AB0.



  ABL 2A5-B0:8 >3 =0 A25B5,   B8E> ?@>H5?B0; =4@59. 



C@0H:8 A=>20  ?>1560;8 C  <5=O ?>  A?8=5, =>  704C<0BLAO >  2>?@>A0E @5;8388  8

0B587<0 O =5 CA?5;.



  C68:8!  CAA:85, GB>-;8? C, 5;:8-?0;:8, 1K205B 65 B0:>5!



"5=L, 8A?C302H0O 5B@0 @:04L528G0 A  AC?@C3>9, 2K1@0;0AL 87 :CAB>2 8  >:070;0AL

42CE<5B@>2>3>  @>AB0  <C6G8=>9  A >:;048AB>9  1>@>4>9,  2  :C@B:5, =0:8=CB>9  =0

B5;L=OH:C. B 3@0640=8=0 25AL<0 >ICB8<> ?0E;> A?8@B=K<.



  K 8728=8B5, @048 >30. 0:C@8BL =5 =0945BAO? 5 284=> =8 E@5=0, 25G=> C  MB8E

0<5@8:0=F52 A25B 2K:;NG0B.    >@>40G 8:=C;, 8 >B  MB>3> A<CB8;AO.   /  20=>2KE

8IC, 2 <03078= ?>H5; 8 701;C48;AO. 5 ?>4A:065B5 :0: : =8< ?@>9B8?



  0;52>, G5@57 420 4><0.   =4@59 =0G0; E>E>B0BL, 8 O 2A;54 70 =8<.



   K  BCB,  @51OB0,  O ?>A<>B@N,  N<>@8ABK,     1>@>40G  2 B5;L=OH:5  70BO=C;AO

A830@5B>9.    GB> MB> 70 ?A8E8 >B 20A =0 <0H8=5 @20=C;8? 0?8;8AL, GB>-;8? 



  0 =5B, MB> B0:,   70<O;AO =4@59.



  >;8F8O A53>4=O 725@AB2C5B, 2K >AB>@>6=55. # ?@8OB5;O <>53> 2 ?@>H;>< 3>4C  =0

45=L 1;03>40@5=8O ?@020 >B>1@0;8. # 20A 2K?8BL G53>-=81C4L >AB0;>AL?



  18605HL, 4>@>3>9. 



  "0:  :0:>3> E@5=0  2K <>;G8B5  :0: ?0@B870=K!  940 :  =0< 2 3>AB8, <K H0H;K:8

70<0@8=>20;8. 



>GL MB0 >:070;0AL  A>2A5< =5 B0:  C6 8 ?;>E0,  20=>2K   ?@8OB=K<8  @51OB0<8, :

B><C 65 7=0:><K<8  <>8E 7=0:><KE, 0  H0H;K:8 2>>1I5 1K;8  2KH5 2AO:8E ?>E20;.  

G0A0 2 420  CB@0, :>340 =4@59  70A=C; =0 A:0<55G:5  2> 42>@5, 0  ?@074=8: 1K; 2

?>;=>< @0730@5, O 2 ?@8?>4=OB>< A>AB>O=88 4CE0 ?>5E0; 4><>9.





 048> @01>B0;>, 8 3>;>A 48:B>@0 ?@54C?@5640; 02B><>18;8AB>2 > E0>A5 =0  4>@>30E.

 MBC =>GL AKBK5 0<5@8:0=FK, ;8H5==K5 A25B>D>@>2 8 D>=0@59, BCB 8 B0< 2 >3@><=KE

:>;8G5AB20E A>25@H0;8 4>@>6=>-B@0=A?>@B=K5 ?@>8AH5AB28O.



  !1>9  2 A8AB5<5  M=5@3>A=0165=8O,    25I0; 48:B>@,    ?@8=O;  :0B0AB@>D8G5A:85

?>A;54AB28O.   57   M;5:B@8G5AB20   >AB0;8AL   2>A5<L   0<5@8:0=A:8E    HB0B>2.

@54AB028B5;8 =0F8>=0;L=>9  M;5:B@8G5A:>9 :><?0=88  ?KB0NBAO ?>=OBL,  GB> 8<5==>

2K720;> AB@0==CN F5?=CN @50:F8N, 2  @57C;LB0B5 :>B>@>9 ?> :@09=59 <5@5  B@84F0BL

<8;;8>=>2 68B5;59 ;8H8;8AL A25B0 2 ?@074=8G=K9 25G5@. 



  %8-E8,   CE<K;L=C;AO O, B25@4> 7=0O, 345 8 :0: =0G0;0AL MB0 F5?=0O @50:F8O,  8

@5H8;, GB> 2 MB>< 3>4C 45=L 1;03>40@5=8O >:070;AO =5 B0:8< C6 8 AB@0H=K<. !B>8;>

<=5  >1 MB><  ?>4C<0BL&  >B  8 =5  1C4L BCB  AC525@=K<: 02B><>18;L  <>9 G8E=C;,

70B@OAAO 8 2 B> 65 <3=>25=85 703;>E. 



  '5@B  1K B51O  ?>1@0;, AB0@0O,  ?>4;0O A:>B8=0!    KH5;  O 87  A51O.   0: BK

?>A<5; :>20@=> ?@540BL <5=O 2 A0<K9 =5?>4E>4OI89 <><5=B, =0 ?CABK==>9 4>@>35!   

!B0@B5@ A:@565B0;, => 42830B5;L =5 ?>4020; 01A>;NB=> =8:0:8E ?@87=0:>2 687=8.





/ 2K;57 87 <0H8=K 8 >:070;AO 2 :@><5H=>9 BL<5. K;> E>;>4=>, 87> @B0 H5; ?0@,  0

=04 3>;>2>9  A25@:0;8 72574K.  >65 2A5<>3CI89,  =8:>340 =5  2845; B0:8E  O@:8E,

1;87:8E 72574, :070;>AL, GB>  8E <>6=> ?>B@>30BL @C:0<8.  >B 8 ;5G=K9 ?CBL,  0

MB>,  =025@=O:0,  .?8B5@.  0,  ?@825B,  AB0@0O  7=0:><0O  -  >;LH0O 542548F0,

?5@525@=CB0O 225@E =>30<8. 



/ >AB@> ?>GC2AB2>20; A2>5 >48=>G5AB2>. 0:8< >1@07>< <K >:070;8AL 2 MB>9  AB@0=5

?>68@0NI59 <8;;8>=K 8=4NH5: 2A53> 70 >48= 45=L? 'B> <K 745AL 45;05<? /,  =4@59,

53>  =54>45;0==K9  4O4NH:0  A  AC?@C3>9,  ?>4?8BK9  1>@>40G  2  B5;L=OH:5,   MB8

A8<?0B8G=K5  20=>2K,  ?>A5;82H85AO 2  A>A54=5<  4><5. 0:  =8GB>6=K  2A5 <K  ?>

A@02=5=8N A  MB>9 G5@=>9  2A5;5==>9. 0:  A<5H=K 3>AC40@AB20  8 3@0=8FK, O7K:8 8

B@048F88. 0: :>@>B:0 =0H0 687=L, ?@5E>4OI8 2A5 AB@0AB8 8 AB@040=8O.  5C;>28<>5

<3=>25=85,  ?H8:...   MB8  72574K  :0: A25B8;8AL,  B0:  8 1C4CB  A25B8BLAO  5I5

<8;;80@4K ;5B. ABL ;8 E>BL  :0:>9-=81C4L, <0;>-<0;LA:8 =8GB>6=K9 A<KA; 2>  2A5<

MB><? >65, =0?@02L <5=O =0 ?CBL 8AB8==K9, O, :065BAO, 701@5; 2 :CABK...



5B:0  ?@51>;L=>  E;5AB=C;0  <5=O  ?>  ;1C, O  2K@C30;AO,  8  A59G0A  65  :0: ?>

2>;H51AB2C 7063;8AL D>=0@8. 8AB8G5A:89 C60A, A<5H0==K9 A 2>AB>@3><, ?>4=O;AO  2

<>59  =5B@572>9 4CH5,  => <3=>25==>  @0AA5O;AO, 81>  O >1=0@C68;,  GB> :CABK,  2

:>B>@KE O 70AB@O;, ?>A065=K C AB5=K ?@84>@>6=>3> 0:->=0;L4A0. 



45 BK, <038O =>G8? 5C65;8 ?@8 M;5:B@8G5A:>< A25B5 =5;L7O 704C<0BLAO >  25G=><?

5B, ?@>70 687=8 @5H8B5;L=> >2;04520;0 4CH>9. ">:C?09B5 0:-"C@:8!"    A25B8;AO

:0==810;LA:89 ?;0:0B  A @04>AB=K<  8=4N:><, 45@60I8<  2 ?5@LOE  :@K;0 30<1C@35@,

A45;0==K9 87 B5; A>@>48G59. 



  '5@B  1K 53>  2A5-B0:8 ?>1@0;,  MB>B 45=L  1;03>40@5=8O,    CAB0;> 1>@<>B0; O,

4>1@02H8AL 4><>9.   "5?5@L 5I5 A <0H8=>9 ?@845BAO @0718@0BLAO.



 BCB 70  >:=>< 70:C40EB0;>. /  >B>428=C; 70=025A:C. 0  C;8F5 C65 A25B0;>,  =04

3>@0<8,  ?>:@KBK<8 ;5A><,  AB5;8;AO BC<0=  8 C  A0<>9 8E  :@><:8 =51>  =0G8=0;>

@>7>25BL.  =0 ;C609:5  15AF5@5<>==> @073C;820;0 =525ABL >B:C40  27O2H0OAO 48:0O

8=4NH:0,  2K:;52K20O GB>-B>  2 B@025.  @5<O >B  2@5<5=8 ?B8F0  :>A8;0 =0  <5=O

:@0A=K< 3;07><, C3@>60NI5 @074C20O H5N.



   >AB>9=>5  7025@H5=85  4=O  8=4NH:8!    24>E=>28;AO  O.     @825BAB2CN B51O,

8AB>@8G5A:0O ?B8F0, ?5@5682H0O  2A5 8AB>@8G5A:85 :0B0:;87<K!  "2>O >4><0H=5==0O,

157K<O==0O @>4AB25==8F0 35@>8G5A:8  A3>@5;0 :0: ?B8F0  $5=8:A. ;>BLN A2>59  >=0

2K25;0 87 AB@>O A8AB5<C M;5:B@>A=0165=8O =0 2A5< 0?04=>< ?>15@56L5  !>548=5==KE

(B0B>2, 0 BK, 48:0O  8 A2>1>4=0O, :0: 8  B2>8 40;5:85 ?@54:8, 2>AAB02  87 ?5?;0,

?0A5HLAO =0  <>59 ;C609:5.    /  704C<0;AO =04  B5<, ?@028;L=>  ;8 >1@0I0BLAO  :

8=4NH:5 ?>-@CAA:8, =0G0; ?5@52>48BL @5GL =0 0=3;89A:89, CB@0B8; AB@>9=>ABL <KA;8

8 70?=C;AO.



>O28;AO ?5@2K9 ;CG8: A>;=F0,  345-B> 240;5:5 8AB5@8G5A:8 70>@0;  ?5BCE. =4NH:0

=52>7<CB8<> ?@>83=>@8@>20;0  <>9 <>=>;>3,  @0725@=C;0AL :>  <=5 704><  8 CH;0 =0

A>A54A:89 CG0AB>:. 



> A;54CNI53> 4=O 1;03>40@5=8O >AB020;>AL @>2=> B@8AB0 H5ABL45AOB ?OBL 4=59.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------